The televised leaders’ debate may not determine the election result, but it will likely play a critical role in the election.
The Oct. 13 debate will chiefly serve as the vehicle that puts two relatively unknown political leaders in front of the electorate for a prolonged period and could finally elevate their public profile.
Compared to Premier John Horgan, BC Liberal leader Andrew Wilkinson and BC Green leader Sonia Furstenau are political unknowns to many. As such, the debate gives them a chance to define themselves in ways not possible previously.
In the weeks leading up to the campaign, the two of them enjoyed a small media presence. Since the campaign began, they have shown up for 30-second sound bites on television newscasts and the odd radio show.
However, a 90-minute debate seen by hundreds of thousands of people is a good opportunity to address some weaknesses.
On their own, debates have not determined the outcome of any particular B.C. election. However, they can have an impact on the final seat count.
In 2005, then-NDP leader Carole James outshone ex-premier Gordon Campbell and that was seen as one reason her party went from having just two seats in the B.C. legislature to a more respectable 33 seats.
James repeated her solid performance in 2009 and boosted her party’s seat count to 35. Again, the debate did not determine an election winner, but it likely played a role in the NDP’s gradual resurgence.
The one debate that had the greatest impact on the outcome is widely considered the very first televised leaders’ debate in 1991.
In a memorable encounter, BC NDP leader Mike Harcourt and Social Credit leader Rita Johnston at one point were bickering over something and talking over each other.
BC Liberal leader Gordon Wilson – a complete unknown at that moment – saw an opening and pounced. He pointed at them both and famously said, “This reminds me of the legislature and here’s a classic example of why nothing gets done in the province of B.C.”
The line was repeated on many television newscasts for days and Wilson’s party shot up in the polls and the Socreds crashed. As a result, that election marked the re-birth of the BC Liberals and the effective end of the once-proud Social Credit party (and, of course, the NDP still won the election).
I do not expect any such magic moments in next Tuesday’s debate.
Wilkinson and Furstenau will likely aim most of their fire at Horgan, who will no doubt try to come off looking like a calm and cool leader during an extraordinary pandemic.
It may not determine the outright winner of the election, but the debate has every chance of making the race tighter than it seems to be right now. We will see if Wilkinson and Furstenau can make the most of a potentially golden opportunity.
Keith Baldrey is chief political reporter for Global BC.
